401(k) vs. 403(b) vs. 412(e)(3)

Choosing the Right Retirement Plan: 401(k) vs. 403(b) vs. 412(e)(3)

When it comes to preparing for retirement, one size does not fit all. Different careers, income levels, and business structures call for different types of retirement savings strategies. The good news? Whether you're a school employee, nonprofit worker, small business owner, or high-income professional, there’s a retirement plan designed to help you build lasting income for your future.

Let’s take a look at three powerful options: the 401(k), 403(b), and 412(e)(3) defined benefit plan.

💼 401(k): The Corporate Workhorse

Ideal For: Employees of private-sector companies and business owners with staff.

A 401(k) is a tax-advantaged retirement plan offered by many employers, allowing employees to defer a portion of their salary on a pre-tax or Roth (after-tax) basis. Employers often sweeten the deal by matching contributions, giving employees “free money” toward retirement.

🔍 Key Benefits:

• Tax-deferred growth or tax-free withdrawals (Roth)

• Annual contributions up to $23,500 in 2025, plus $7,500 catch-up at age 50+

• Optional special catch-up: $34,750 for ages 60–63

• Employer contributions can boost total annual deposits up to $81,250

• Withdrawals begin at age 73 (or retirement, if later)

• 10% penalty for early withdrawal (unless exceptions apply)

💡 Best Practice: Contribute enough to get your full employer match—and consider increasing your contributions each year.

🏫 403(b): Tailored for Teachers & Nonprofits

Ideal For: Public school employees, university staff, and workers at tax-exempt organizations (501(c)(3)).

The 403(b) works much like a 401(k) but is available only to certain public service and nonprofit employees. Contributions are tax-deferred unless made as Roth deferrals, and investment options often include annuities or mutual funds.

🔍 Key Benefits:

• Pre-tax or Roth contributions

• Same limits as the 401(k): up to $23,500 (plus catch-ups)

• Unique 15-year service rule: Additional $3,000/year for eligible long-term employees

• Tax-deferred growth and potential employer contributions

• Withdrawals taxed as ordinary income, unless Roth-qualified

• Distributions required by age 73 (or retirement, if later)

💡 Watch Out: Fees and limited investment options can eat into returns. It’s wise to compare 403(b) options with IRAs or other supplemental plans.

🏢 412(e)(3): The Small Business Power Plan

Ideal For: Older, high-earning business owners (often in professional fields) with consistent cash flow and few employees.

The 412(e)(3) is a defined benefit plan that’s fully funded with annuity and life insurance products—offering guaranteed retirement income. It’s a great solution for business owners who want to maximize tax-deductible contributions and create significant retirement benefits quickly.

🔍 Key Benefits:

• Funded entirely by the employer

• Contributions are often higher than with other plans—great for catch-up

• Offers guaranteed payouts based on insurance and annuity contracts

• May include income tax-free death benefits for heirs

• No stock market risk

• Exempt from the IRS’s minimum funding rules

⚠️ Considerations:

• Maximum benefit is capped ($280,000/year or 3-year comp average)

• Requires annual funding and administrative oversight

• Not suitable for businesses with high employee turnover

💡 Best Fit: Business owners age 50+ needing to “catch up” on retirement savings quickly while locking in lifetime income.

📊 Which One Is Right for You?

Feature 401(k) 403(b) 412(e)(3)

Employer Type Private Sector Public & Nonprofit Small Business Owners

Employee Contributions Yes Yes No

Employer Contributions Optional Optional Required

Investment Options Broad (Stocks/ETFs) Annuities, Mutual Funds Annuities + Life Insurance

Contribution Limit (2025) $23.5K + catch-up $23.5K + catch-up Actuarially determined, often higher

Market Participation Yes Yes No (guaranteed values only)

Ideal For General workforce Educators/Nonprofits High-income owners over 50

🧠 Final Thoughts: Your Retirement Strategy Should Fit Your Life

Retirement planning isn’t just about saving money—it’s about making smart choices with taxes, timing, and risk in mind. Whether you’re contributing to a 403(b) at a university, maxing out a 401(k) in a corporate job, or funding a 412(e)(3) plan to secure a guaranteed pension, the best plan is the one aligned with your goals.

📞 Need help choosing or comparing retirement options?

Let’s talk. I specialize in guiding individuals, small business owners, and educators through personalized strategies that build confident retirements—with less tax stress.

📅 Schedule your free strategy session today. Your future self will thank you.

‍